Reviews

In the comments section of my last post, my friend Leighton gives a link to a review for Midnighter #1 (thanks, Leighton, and thanks again for trying to sell some comics for me!). Fortunately it was a good one–I had sworn off reading reviews because they can depress me or even anger me and rarely if ever had any constructive criticism, but I’ve read a few for this book because I was anticipating a little controversy and was too curious to resist.

I have to say most reviews have been favorable, but a few have been vicious(one guy writes about how I’ve lost it and am too lazy to draw detailed backgrounds anymore–nevermind that this book took place in a desert and a featureless metal cell & corridor…) and a few have just missed the point, dwelling on either Midnighter’s sexuality not being featured heavily enough or how the subject has been dealt with in a clumsy and heavy-handed way. The award for missing the point the most, however, goes to the internet pundit who was outraged that–according to him– Midnighter killed U.S. troops in this issue(for the record: he killed a caucasian mercenary–no U.S. flag or anything similar anywhere on his fatigues–and destroyed some tanks being used by unscrupulous local chumps taking advantage of a de-stabilized Afghanistan to work out old tribal grudges…no American soldiers or patriots or even Republicans were harmed in the making of this comic book).
…I guess it’s kinda obvious I’m letting ’em get to me again! So…I’m going to start avoiding reviews again and continue trying to just draw as well as I can and tell stories to the best of my abilities. That’s why I got into comics, after all.
As for what the Midnighter comic and character are all about, I’ll let someone more capable and qualified talk about that: HERE is a link to an interview with Midnighter writer Garth Ennis(actually it’s kind of a press release, I think, which is being used all over the place–Xan & I read almost the exact same text in a UK fanzine in Forbidden Planet in London).
–C
Here’s a small preview of Midnighter #2–my favorite page from that issue, in pencillled form. Too bad I’m too lazy to draw detailed backgrounds anymore or this would have been a really cool page…
Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Reviews

  1. I was all ready to make a comment about how fabulous the detail is in issue #2, but you beat me to it! I love the art in this issue-you really captured the hell that is trench warfare.Your art never fails to impress me.

  2. Ignore ’em – there are people on the ‘net who will criticize ANYTHING, because they think it makes them look more discerning/refined/whatever. I think the book looks fantastic!

  3. Thanks, guys(In case it looks strange to anyone–like i’m giving myself a pep talk or something weird–I’m assuming Xan wrote that first comment–it just shows up as authored by “Chris & Xan”)! The support is much appreciated! Like I said, most reviews were indeed favorable…just a few kind of got my hackles up…which is why i, as fogger advises, usually ignore them…but in this case I couldn’t resist. Oh, well–I’m proud of everything I’ve done recently, like the last couple of Tom Strong issues, the Ex Machina Special, and most of Ocean. Midnighter is going to be a bit of an experiment for me at times(I’m trying to do something much darker, literally and figuratively, than what I’m used to, as well as tackling action sequences like none I’ve ever had to before…issue #3 is essentially a twenty page fight scene!), so I may fail as much as I succeed, but I’m giving it my best shot. There have been comics I’ve drawn that have had maybe one or two pages I could even stand to look at after I finished them, but Midnighter #1 has maybe two or three pages I CAN’T stand to look at, and #2 has even less. ‘Nuff said for now! Thanks again for the morale boost! –C

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s